Qiao's Data vs. TBI's Feelings - Unqualified Opinions #13

do halvings lead to bitcoin price pumps?

Subscribe now

tl;dr: Qiao argues (with data) that the bitcoin halving does not by itself spark rallies or new bull markets. (Counterpoints welcome.) If you want to join our intense internal debates on crypto markets and fundamentals (and actually build the tools to resolve some of these debates), check out our careers page. Not an engineer? That’s ok. Join our analyst community.


The Bitcoin Halving Bull Meme - Messari’s Unqualified Opinions #13

(6 minute read)

Lately there’s been renewed hype that “bitcoin will pump around halving events.”

This is a bad thesis.

The idea works something like this. The price of Bitcoin is highly volatile, so miners generally cash out after mining new blocks. However, every four years (every 210,000 blocks to be exact), Bitcoin’s block reward halves. Less reward means less cashing out, and as a result, the selling pressure from miners decreases. With less selling, the market faces a supply shock (demand is unchanged), and that leads to a price rally.

Moreover, charts like the one below get thrown around on Twitter and Telegram to support this. Indeed, the price of Bitcoin does seem to be substantially higher after the halvings on 11/28/2012 and 07/09/2016.


Sounds like a plausible thesis and good supporting evidence, right?

Not so fast.

Because “halvings” are expected events, you can also argue potential market impact is priced in well ahead of time. In plain English, you cannot predictably beat the market by using public information such as the knowledge that block rewards will halve.

This is the famous “market efficiency” argument, and it’s a view I largely hold.

No market (Bitcoin included) is always 100% efficient. As a trader myself, I know this well. But I will say that the Bitcoin market appears efficient with respect to how it prices in halving events. Let’s look at the data.

Bitcoin’s Historical Returns

I’m a data maximalist.

If you look at the 2016 bitcoin halving, the returns of the market one week, one-month, and one quarter after the halving are mediocre. In 2012, the market performed well, but it still didn’t meaningfully outperform the historical average. At most, we have mixed results from two data points.

Some proponents of the halving narrative will argue that the price increase actually occurs before the halving, because traders start buying in anticipation of the halving. Unfortunately, the data doesn’t support this either. The returns prior to the halvings are still disastrous compared to the historical average.

* To calculate the historical average, we compute the 1-week, 1-month, and 1-quarter return for every day since 2009, and then take the average across all the days. If you bought Bitcoin on any random day, what would your returns look like be?

Block Rewards vs. Trading Volume
One plausible explanation of this lack of causal relationship between halving and returns is that block rewards are way too small compared to trading volume. According to OnChainFX, the change in block reward during the next halving will be nearly 3 orders of magnitude lower than the daily trading volume.


In other words, the decrease in supply from miners is miniscule relative to aggregate demand. Note that this argument is orthogonal to the market efficiency argument.

Confirmation Bias

The above evidence suggests the halving thesis is unfounded. It’s more likely that other day-to-day or month-to-month trends move the market to a much greater degree, and bitcoin’s known scarcity is a long-term bullish trend that has helped to steadily drive long term growth.

The more interesting question we should ask ourselves is: what can we learn from the hype around unfounded theses more generally?

For starters, always look out for confirmation bias.

It’s a dangerous habit that can cost investors a lot of money. We have subconscious tendencies to look for evidence that support our existing beliefs and, in particular, our current investment positions. People who are short tend to overweight information unfavorable to Bitcoin. Those who are long Bitcoin tend to overweight information that’s favorable to Bitcoin, which could explain this new “wait for the halving” meme.

No one is immune from confirmation bias. Not even the best of the investors.

But the best investors are conscious of their own cognitive deficiencies, and work very hard to mentally fight against them with good, statistically significant, data.

Two data points isn’t enough.

- Qiao

Debate with me on Twitter. It’s one of the best ways to improve our understanding of the world together.

[TBI Note: Qiao’s data is pretty interesting, but a teacher once told me that as a precious snowflake my feelings matter, so I’m going to use those as a counter-argument. I don’t like that Qiao’s data conflicts with my feelings, so I reject it.]

News & Analyses

Messari Compression Algorithm

Content and thoughts from around the web as summarized by the Messari team.

[Analysis] Utility token market cap and equity market cap are not comparable – Stephanie Hurder, PhD

Citing research from MIT and University of Toronto, Stephanie explains the significant differences between token and equity valuations. The value of equity is a function of the profits of a business over that business's life. On the other hand, the value of a token (in theory) should be driven by the value of goods or services the token can buy in a single period - how much do you need to hold in reserve in order to participate in that micro-economy. If a token’s “market cap” is greater than the revenue of the platform in a single period of operation, then it might be overvalued. [TBI Note: This is the problem with “payment tokens.” There’s no reason to hold them for any non-trivial length of time. You buy the token, and complete the payment for service. The vendor receives the token and they can sell it immediately.] (Source)

📝 P2P payments startup launches Circle Research

Circle launched Circle Research on Tuesday with an aim to provide data and insights about specific crypto assets. They currently offer primers on EOS , Cardano, and Qtum. The division’s lead analyst, Ria, consistently puts out great research. Her reports (and all of Circle Research’s future reports) will be included in our own research database under the “resource section” (e.g. Cardano) (Messari | Source)

Quick Bits (Don't read that, I read it for you)

Choke Points (Exchange News)

  • 🚫 Binance will delist BCN, CHAT, ICN, TRIG. Factors considered in delisting coins: a network/smart contract’s stability, evidence of unethical or fraudulent conduct, and unresponsiveness to periodic due diligence. (Messari | Source)

Startup Signals (ICOs, Cryptos, and Startups)

  • 🍑  SpankChain disclosed an attack that led to a loss of approximately $38,000 from the network due to a smart contract bug. It also caused $4,000 in SpankChain's BOOTY token to be frozen. Of the losses, $9,300 worth of ether and BOOTY belonged to users. The company plans to make them whole via an airdrop. (Messari | Source)

  • 💬 South Korean messaging giant Kakao announced the launch of a test network of its own blockchain, Klatyn. The proprietary blockchain testnet was made available to ten invited partners. (Messari | Source)

  • 🤝   Forbes announced it will become the first major media brand to begin experimenting with publishing content to the Civil platform. Under the agreement, Forbes will begin to publish metadata from select articles to the Ethereum blockchain via Civil in the first quarter of 2019. (Messari | Source)

  • 💸 Former Bitmain chip designer Yang Zuoxing hopes to IPO his own mining hardware company, MicroBT, this year, joining a slew of others including Canaan and Ebang. The two-year old startup has raised $22 million from individual investors thus far.  (Messari | Source)

The Powers That Be (Legal/Reg/Policy)

  • 🆕 Dubai will soon launch its own state-developed cryptocurrency, emCash. emCredit, the UAE's first official credit bureau, is pushing adoption of the currency by distributing Pundi X point-of-sale devices at government storefronts. (Messari | Source)

  • 🛂 Venezuelans seeking passports must pay in petro, the government-backed cryptocurrency. The new passports cost four times the national monthly minimum wage. Most people are trapped. (Messari | Source)

  • 🇹🇼  Taiwanese lawmaker Jason Hsu proposed for crypto to be included under Taiwan’s Money Laundering Control Act in an amendment announced on Tuesday. Crypto exchanges in Taiwan will become obligated to record transaction records and reports of suspicious activity as part of preventing money laundering once it takes effect. (Messari | Source)

  • 🏦 Crypto exchange Rain Financial has opened its public waiting list after a year in the Central Bank of Bahrain's fintech sandboxand expects to launch as a fully fledged business in early 2019. (Messari | Source)

Did I miss something?

Send me the link, your twitter handle and your best imitation compression algorithm write up. If I like it, I’ll include your bit next issue (with attribution).


Community Updates

Podcast Recap

We host & produce our own podcast on Spotify, iTunes, Soundcloud, and Google Play. Last week, Katherine was on the ground at Crypto Springs where she interviewed a bunch of speakers and attendees about their experience at the invite-only conference.

Apple Podcasts: here. Spotify: here. Soundcloud: here. Google play: here. Enjoy!

Shameless Plugs

We're Hiring:

We’ve got five engineering reqs up on our careers page. Join our fast growing team in NYC; work with crypto OGs, and former Bloomberg/Palantir engineers; and access a network that sets you up for the rest of your career. Apply here!

️Upcoming Travel:

Hit us up while we’re at:

  • SFBW, San Francisco, October 8-12th

  • Money 20/20, Las Vegas, October 21-24th

  • DevCon, Prague, Czech Republic October 30–November 2, 2018

Join Our Community!

  • If you are interested in helping us crowdsource token project details, or want to join our community to share your expertise, wed love to have you on board! Take a second to fill out an application and we will get back to you soon. Going forward, we’ll be capping new members at 15 each week to keep things running smoothly. If you haven’t heard back, you are probably in the queue.

Like what you read? Share it! Hate what you read? Let me know @MessariCrypto.